ENHEIT

payless.host

HostGator vs SherlockHost: Which Is Cheaper Long-Term?

Updated Nov 22, 2026

Three-year cost of the providers in: HostGator vs SherlockHost: Which Is Cheaper Long-Term?
What the cheapest hosting plan of each costs over three years, at the prices on their own sites.
Use this chart on your site

The finding

SherlockHost charges £2.49 per month from signup through year three. HostGator starts cheaper in dollars but doubles or triples when the introductory term ends after 36 months. The trade-off: SherlockHost's price is honest and holds, but plans advertised as "unlimited" make what you actually receive unclear. HostGator defines limits, but the gap between what you pay first and what you pay later is wide.

What each costs now

SherlockHost's Linux Hosting start, Website Builder, and Web Hosting plans each cost £2.49 per month. That price does not change at renewal.

HostGator's Hatchling plan costs 3.75 USD per month for the first three years, with a three-year total of 135.00 USD. The Baby plan is 4.50 USD per month, totalling 162.00 USD over three years. The Business plan costs 6.25 USD per month for 225.00 USD over three years.

What each costs at renewal

SherlockHost's price remains £2.49 per month on its entry-level plans. A customer paying that price in month one pays it in month thirty-seven.

HostGator's Hatchling renews at 10.99 USD after 36 months — nearly three times the introductory rate. The Baby plan renews at 16.49 USD, more than triple the initial 4.50 USD. Business renews at 21.99 USD, three and a half times the 6.25 USD starting price.

Higher tiers

SherlockHost's Linux Hosting pro costs 6.99 GBP per month, and Linux Hosting maximum costs 9.99 GBP per month, both at the same price from signup onward. Windows plans start at 3.49 GBP for the entry tier and reach 24.99 GBP for Windows Hosting maximum.

HostGator's Pro plan costs 13.95 USD per month initially, with a three-year total of 502.20 USD, and renews at 29.69 USD — more than double.

The trade-off

SherlockHost's advantage is price certainty. What you pay in the first month is what you pay in the fourth year. The disadvantage is that "unlimited" appears throughout its plan descriptions, making resource limits and fair-use policies impossible to confirm from the pricing page alone. A customer cannot judge whether the plan will support their actual usage.

HostGator defines what each plan includes. Limits are stated. The renewal price is published. The cost is predictable, but only after accounting for the increase that arrives in month thirty-seven. A customer who forgets that increase or assumes the introductory rate will hold has misjudged what they will pay by two or three times.

Who each suits

SherlockHost suits someone who values a price that does not change and who can verify through support or documentation what "unlimited" means in practice before committing. The same monthly cost from start to finish removes one variable.

HostGator suits someone deciding on a three-year commitment who wants clarity on what the plan includes and is prepared for the price to double or triple when that term ends. The introductory rate is low if paid upfront, but only for thirty-six months.

The providers in this article